GAME-ASSAULT.COM
Reviews by gamers,
for gamers.

News
Reviews
Features
Editorial
Forum
Poll
Staff
Contact Us
Links
Homepage
Privacy Policy

Get Firefox!

gameassault.com - NFL 2K1 Review
Amazon.com sells games!MTV Music Generator
MSRP: $29.95
Number of Players: 1 
Developer: Jester
Publisher: Codemasters USA
Reviewer: Robert Dirom

In the grand scheme of things, MTV Music Generator isn't really much of a game, despite Codemasters' efforts to toss in gameplay elements.  But despite this, the program isn't anywhere near being a lost cause – in fact, for the casual music lover who wants to make his or her own songs, this may be just what the doctor ordered. 

MTV Music Generator is more than a simple music program, but not that much more. The program offers a "Music Jam" mode, which allows you to "jam" live on your own or with friends (this can be done over a LAN or the Internet). This is more a novelty than anything else, and I suspect very few people will use this capability. It's mildly entertaining, but not worth buying a copy of the program. Codemasters has established a chat room where budding musicians can find people to jam with. It's not quite the matchmaking software that most software comes with these days, but MTV Music Generator is not best enjoyed as a multiplayer program. 

The core of the program is the music creation aspect, which is very easy to use and can generate good results with a minimal effort. Numerous pre-designed riffs have been included in the software - users can cobble these together to develop an interesting soundscape, or they can take things into their own hands and develop riffs of their own, using hundreds of available samples. If the program doesn't have the right sample, users can also create their own, either from CD audio or .wav files. It's this kind of flexibility that makes MTV Music Generator a great value. Users with a MIDI keyboard can create new riffs through their keyboards, which is a lot more comfortable than using a computer keyboard or mouse to do it. Even without creating your own riffs, the number of unique songs you could create with the stock riffs boggles the mind. Check out the sample song we've created as an example of what can be done with the basic riffs. The song only took about a half hour to put together and while it's rather raw, using only a handful of riffs, it barely scratches the surface of what's possible with MTV Music Generator. For a $30 package, there's a lot of value to be had here.  

Unfortunately, as a $30 package, there are also some drawbacks. Many of the riffs and samples aren't very clean, resulting in a slightly annoying listening experience. Thanks to one such riff, I had to replace the bass line in one of the early songs I created with the program, totally changing its overall sound and feel. Another problem is that many of the samples are recorded at different pitches, so you have to do some mental math to transpose your musical designs to the appropriate key. Otherwise, the software is pretty solid, although a few interface changes and extra options could be added to make it even easier to use (a notable omission is the lack of an option to save files as MP3s – to do this, users must first save as a .WAV file and then use a separate MP3 encoder not included with the program).  

Now that you've created a song, MTV Music Generator will let you create a video to go along with it. The video editor is not so extravagant as to give you hordes of dancers to play around with - you'll basically be creating a light show to accompany your song. Still, it's a pretty neat tool... and if you don't want to create your own video, the program can auto-generate one. You can get some pretty impressive results, but the video editor is obviously not the focus of the software, and many users won't spend a lot of time with it.

MTV Music Generator is an excellent music creation program for the price. It probably won't displace higher-end professional music software, but it's powerful enough that most recreational users will be able to do whatever their hearts desire. A great, solid piece of software that lacks polish in places.

Graphics

7.0

The interface looks clean and the video tracks look pretty good, but nothing outstanding on either count.  
Sound & Music 8.0 In the end, how good the program sounds is up to the user. Points docked for crackly samples and riffs.
Control 8.0 The interface is easy to use, although it could use a few refinements. Samples recorded in different keys are frustrating. A "Save as MP3" option is conspicuously absent.  
Replay Value

10

This program will fit the bill whenever you've got the urge to make music.
Fun Factor

8.0

If you like music, you should have a good time with MTV Music Generator. It might not match the thrill of deathmatching or building an empire, but creating music is a fun and rewarding experience.  
Overall

8.0

A great package with a few annoying drawbacks, MTV Music Generator offers users a lot of bang for the buck.

Discuss this review in our FORUM

About our Ratings

News | Reviews | Features | Editorial | Contest
Forum | Staff | Contact Us | Voting Booth | Links | Homepage